What Is The Deal With Lana Del Rey? A Timeline

Published on February 2nd, 2012 in: Critics/Criticism, Feminism, Media, Music, Teh Sex, The Internets |

By Less Lee Moore

I never even heard of Lana Del Rey until I saw this posted on a friend’s Facebook wall on January 14: “What is this Lana Del Rey shit?”

lana del rey1

It was, of course, a reference to that infamous, scandalous, controversial, polarizing (pick one or come up with your own) Saturday Night Live performance. I don’t watch SNL so I didn’t see it.

The next day, January 15, another Facebook friend posted a link to Lana Del Rey’s video for “Born To Die.” I listened to it. I loved her voice and I thought the song was rather intriguing and different. Del Rey was certainly beautiful, with a distinctive look and sound. I watched a few more videos of hers “Blue Jeans,” “Video Games,” and “Mermaid Motel.” They were all good.

Then I started reading online about the backlash before the SNL backlash. How Del Rey was an indie poseur, blah blah blah. I felt bad for the poor girl. I felt like if everyone was going to hate on her, I was going to like her just to spite people. (I can’t help it; it’s what I do.)

Other than posting a link to the “Born To Die” video on my own Facebook wall and a link to the January 16 Brian Williams email article on Gawker, I have not posted much about her online. Yet I couldn’t escape the haterade that everyone on the Internet seemed to be drinking. It was everywhere I looked and I wasn’t looking for it. Within about a week, she came up in a real-life conversation and that’s when I started Googling her.

New York Magazine‘s Entertainment section has a nice timeline of events that you can check out here. I admit it looks like I’m copying them with my own timeline below, but mine is a bit different.

Rather than try to dissect and comment on each and every blog post I’ve read about Lana Del Rey (which would surely require at least a week and I do have other things to do) or even the ones I’m linking below, I’m just going to include some salient quotes and let you be the judge.

At this point, you’re going to think what you want to think about Lana Del Rey so maybe you’re thinking “why bother?” I will point out that these links are available to everyone with a computer and an Internet connection. It seems like people (including music blogs and others) are content to follow the meme of the moment without questioning it (or the biases of the blogosphere, much less their own biases) or even doing their own research. I wanted to do my own research and decide for myself. So here you go.

2008

Lizzy Grant, 2008

Index Magazine, Interview with Lizzy Grant with Brea Tremblay
Brea: So the EP has three songs—any plans to release a full CD?
Lizzy: Yes, when I recorded with Davey [David Kahne], we recorded 13 songs. So I was never expecting to release an EP, but when iTunes came to us, and became fervent supporters and said, “put out anything and we’ll give you the artist’s spotlight.” We decided, okay, we’ll just put out an EP, which was released on October 21.

Brea: What type of things would you move on to?

lizzy grant trailer
Photo from Index Magazine

Lizzy: I always expect that once I do something, I’m going be able to transition into this better life, like maybe move somewhere else or get to know more people. Ideally, I would like to move back to a little part of New Jersey or Coney Island and have people to work with on little projects like music videos, because I do much better in a box. Performing is really, really hard for me, so I would just like to have more people and more money to do more sexy projects.

Brea: Where do you see a record like this being played?
Lizzy: That’s a good question. I was sure that I knew, but I’ve been wrong. For instance, I’ve been singing recently at private parties for young Wall Street, and not so young Wall Street, and I’m surprised that they like the music. I guess that’s not really a demographic though is it?

October 27, 2008

Spotlight On: Lizzy Grant
Radio Exile, post by Elie Z. Perler
Relatively new to the indie scene, striking chanteuse Lizzy Grant [Official Site, Myspace] possesses an unrelenting charm that will no doubt melt the masses. Her brand of music is at once delectable, blending the best elements of jazz, folk, and rock. And her vocal delivery effectively channels the likes of Ella Fitzgerald and Billy [sic] Holiday, with a slight twist of Flunk. It only takes one listen to become hooked to the cool, calculated confidence and quirky lyrical quips. Indeed, Grant enchantingly whisper-sings of encounters at Coney Island and Diamond David Lee Roth.

rob lizzy
Lizzy Grant and her father Rob
Photo dated May 2008 from
DN Journal

October 29, 2008

The Lowdown
DN Journal, The Domain Industry News Magazine, post by Ron Jackson
Lizzy performed at the CMJ Music Festival in New York last Friday night and quite a buzz is starting to develop about her in the music blogosphere. You can get Lizzy’s EP at iTunes and also check out the video on the home page at her website.

December 2, 2008

Lizzy Grant (12/2/08, National Underground, NYC)
Radio Exile, post by Elie Z. Perler
Armed with a distinct voice to melt and enough reverb to drown, the sultry chanteuse charmingly ambled through an abbreviated set of infectious original compositions.

Show Notes from Shawn M. Smith: Despite being crippled by a “terrible stage fright” as she would describe it, there is a certain “something” about Lizzy that I really connect with. Maybe its growing up poor-ish in Upstate NY and how the whole “trailer park darling” aspect makes so very much sense to me. Perhaps it is that I relate to her lyrics in second hand way; most of her lyrical content sounds like the secret fears and the protected diary entries from a little girl’s stolen journal.

Show Notes From Tom W: Lizzy’s entire set made me feel as if I were in some smoky early ’60s lounge; her voice is from a different era and her presence, naturally coy and shy, gives off this slightly plastic, slightly Warholian feel.

Check out Lizzy now, when you can still see her in an intimate and cozy venue because she is unlikely to be playing them for long.

December 13, 2008

Lizzy Grant @ Living Room 12/16 8PM FREE
Wiredset.com, post by Mark Ghuneim

2009

January 20, 2009

Interview: Singer/Songwriter Lizzy Grant on Cheap Thrills, Elvis, The Flamingos, Trailer Parks, and Coney Island
Huff Post Entertainment, Interview by Felicia C. Sullivan
FCS: Many artists today are deliberate in the way their image is packaged and how their music is positioned. Their sound is neatly manufactured; one sometimes wonders if lyrics were written by committee. And then there are other artists—renegades and risk-takers. Their sound is a hybrid of genres; their videos are odd, magical, unexpected—a visual representation of the songs and stories in the artist’s head. I dare say that I’d include you in the latter. Your music is organic and daring in the way that artists who try to find their story, work out their obsessions, and find themselves, often is. Have you considered yourself an artist who refuses to color in the lines? How important is it for one to be as unpackaged as possible?

LG: I guess I haven’t colored in the lines of a corporate picture, but making up the rules for myself comes with just as many problems as following someone else’s. It’s not important to me to be unpackaged. If it looks like I don’t know what I’m doing, it’s because I don’t. But, if someone came along with a better idea of how to do things, I would take it.

I think obsession is a good word to talk about. I live in my obsessions and then the music comes from there. Living that way and writing from that place doesn’t make for a “color in the lines” mold. And yet, the songs and the videos and the image go together well because they all come from the same place. So, maybe I’m not deliberate about the packaging, but I am deliberate at trying to do things that I adore.

2010

January 5, 2010

The Lowdown: Hypnotic New Album from Domainer’s Daughter Lana Del Ray (AKA Lizzy Grant) Now Available on iTunes
DN Journal, The Domain Industry News Magazine, post by Ron Jackson
In October I told you about the debut release (a 3-track EP called Kill Kill) from recording artist Lizzy Grant, the daughter of veteran domain investor Rob Grant who was the subject of our April 2008 Cover Story. Today, Lizzy’s first full-length album Lana Del Ray (a moniker that also serves as her stage name) went up for sale on iTunes (just $9.99 for the 13-track album or 99 cents for any of the individual songs).

Knowing Lizzy’s immense talent I downloaded the album as soon as it was released and am listening to it (for the second time) as I write this. I can tell you with 100% honesty that I love it.

She is a wonderful young woman who has the complete package needed to break through in the music business—a unique sound, songs with inescapable hooks, an engaging personality and a great look.

(Google results for “what is a domain investor”—Ed.)

lizzy grant flag
Photo from
Adirondack Daily Enterprise

January 28, 2010

Lizzy Grant aka. Lana Del Ray releases album
Adirondack Daily Enterprise, article by Jessica Collier
Now 24 years old, Lizzy Grant is on her way. Earlier this month, she released her first professionally produced album, “Kill Kill,” under the stage name Lana Del Ray on the label Five Points Records, and it is now available for purchase on iTunes and other Web sites.

Lizzy said she liked that Kahne quickly understood her vision.

She told him she wanted the album to be cinematic. She was also hoping it would reflect her affection for nostalgic things like Coney Island and black and white movies.

“He kind of got my whole vibe right away,” she said.

She writes all her own music, and she said her lyrics tend to be a reflection on actual incidents in her life.

“There will be two true verses, then I’ll make up the third; just rhyme it out,” Grant said.

Her father, who has a history in advertising and has been helping his daughter market her album, said it’s very exciting to live vicariously through her.

“It’s a girl from an upstate New York town who may be on the verge of something great,” he said.

2011

August 3, 2011

Best New Track
Pitchfork, post by Ian Cohen
So even if I really wish she hadn’t taken it there with this whole “gangsta Nancy Sinatra” thing, at the very least she’s prevented it from being used by someone unworthy of our attention.

ldr video games

August 30, 2011

Features: Rising
Pitchfork, interview by Ryan Dombal
Pitchfork: How did you meet the pretty-well-known producer of your first album, David Kahne?
Lana Del Rey: When I was 18 I was signed to an indie label and we sent my demos to five producers. David called us 10 minutes later and asked if we could start working the next day. We spent every day for five months on the record with Coney Island and hope as the touchstones for the sound.

Pitchfork: What did you learn about music and the industry from releasing that album?
LDR: I learned that there’s no reason why people decide they like music when they do. Even if you’re the best singer in the world, there’s a good chance no one will ever hear you. You make a decision to keep singing or to stop. I’ve been singing in Brooklyn since I was 17 and no one in the industry cared at all. I haven’t changed a thing since then and yet things seem to be turning around for me. Perhaps the angels decided to shine on me for a little while.

Pitchfork: Your dad is a successful domain investor, but I read that you were living in a trailer park a few years ago. Do you fetishize that trailer park lifestyle?
LDR: My dad is an entrepreneur and an innovator. Being an entrepreneur doesn’t make you a rich tycoon and being an innovator doesn’t mean that you’re successful. It just means that you’re interesting. No one cares that I lived in a park—Dad loves trailers and is getting one in the Everglades. My first record label gave me a small check and I moved into a park near Manhattan. It’s not something I cared to even share but people keep asking me about it. My songs are cinematic so they seem to reference a glamorous era or fetishize certain lifestyles, but that’s not my aim. I’m not trying to create an image or a persona. I’m just singing because that’s what I know how to do.

September 9, 2011

check out Lana Del Rey (formerly Lizzy Grant)—new video released, ‘debut’ shows announced
Brooklyn Vegan, post by Andrew Sacher
NY Singer/songwriter Lizzy Grant, who now goes by the name of Lana Del Rey, is releasing the new single “Video Games” b/w “Blue Jeans” on October 16 digitally and on 7″ vinyl the next day on Stranger Records. The vinyl is available for pre-order at the Stranger Records webstore. You can also watch videos of both tracks and check out the cover art below.

It’s hard to pay attention to Lana Del Rey without noticing her booming style. She’s got a number of portraits, like the one above, evoking images of vintage film stars and models. Her songs possess a strong sense of classic pop with lyrical references to James Dean, old bars, and guns. But Lana Del Rey’s style doesn’t come without substance. She sings with a bold, sultry delivery, bearing conversational lyrics and moody musical passages that present much more than mere nostalgia.
And people are taking notice. Lana has been featured everywhere from Pitchfork to Stereogum to KCRW to The Guardian. The video for “Blue Jeans” (that you can watch below) was posted to YouTube today and already has almost 20,000 views as of this post.

Fans of Lizzy Grant have probably seen her play at places like the National Underground, the Living Room, and even at Fordham University in 2008 with Mirah and The Blow. She however has never played a show as Lana Del Ray. Therefore the two US shows that were just announced are Lana’s live debut.

September 12, 2011

Hipster Runoff, first post of many
Is Lana Del Rey the next overrated, marginally talented but TOTALLY HOT female in indie?

September 22, 2011

Hipster Music Blogs Need to Get Over Their ‘Authenticity’ Problem
Gawker, post by Bryan Moylan

Comment by Nigerian Business Executive: Brian, thanks for introducing me to her. Not only do I love her love her voice and find her music intriguing. I could not care less about pumped up lips and management teams. It’s the tunes I’m after and, unless she’s a mass-murderer or pedophile, if there are considerations other than music for judging a musician I am very happy to be excluded from any kind of cool music loving clique. Moreover, the fact that I’m not “supposed” to like her makes me like her more. The blogs are doing her management team’s work excellently! Thanks!

Comment by The Late Innings: On one hand, it could be the case that the (re-)packaging of Lizzy Grant as “Lana Del Rey” by her management/PR firm has been sloppy: it doesn’t take too much internet sleuthing to find the breadcrumb trail between Lizzy Grant’s previous life and her new persona.

But I can’t believe her PR firm is that inept—another possible conclusion is that the packaging and marketing of LDR has been made intentionally obvious so that the marketing campaign itself would generate a discussion (and by extension, interest in LDR). There’s no way that her PR firm could hide every trace of her previous existence (nor did they try to—it’s not too hard to find her LG’s old ReverbNation page, for example); instead, they counted on the scoop-hungry blogosphere to do work to figure out who is the voice behind “Video Games”.

Plenty of blog posts (some admiring, some scathing) have included information about her past, presented as though they were uncovering the real truth about LDR. Hipster Runoff has devoted several posts about her that claim to expose her for what she is (or are these parodies of other blogger’s “discoveries”? I can’t tell.) Regardless, that’s what was intended all along, I think. The PR campaign that we see on the surface is intended to be transparent—the one that’s going on behind the scenes is the parceling out of information about her to keep stringing the blogosphere along.

(Or now have I fallen into the trap myself? I’ve claimed to discover the real truth about LDR!)

September 30, 2011

Why We Fight: The Imagination of Lana Del Rey
Pitchfork, Nitsuh Abebe discusses the sharp rise of divisive Internet star Lana Del Rey
It’s a tricky thing. Back when Del Rey was Lizzy Grant, she struggled for years in a field where, to put it uncharitably, artists are not much encouraged to be openly imaginative. Your run-of-the-mill singer-songwriter has lots of room to exercise vocal skill and musical sophistication, but they exist in an awfully untheatrical world—an earnest, “gimmick”-free space that doesn’t accommodate much in the way of creative personas. The whole genre is damn near allergic to pretense. Judging by her interviews, Del Rey found that space pretty frustrating, for career reasons as much as creative ones. So what audience could she communicate with better?

If that sounds like a cynical question—if it sounds wrong to “choose” an audience, rather than let one naturally accrete around you—consider just how fragmented the music world is at this point: Recording artists need to find a home just as much as touring bands need to pick which venues to play. (I feel silly even typing “music world,” singular, as opposed to “worlds.”) Del Rey has the ear and the ambition for a pop audience, and an aesthetic that makes an effective splash around the “indie” press.

Three months ago

Some Kinda Gypsy Tumblr
‘Who IS indie?’—Lana Del Rey
Wish my Rolling Stone ‘Hot Issue’ piece on Lana Del Rey could have fit more words, but alas. Here’s a portion of my conversation with her that didn’t make it into the mag . . .

Before this, did you ever concern yourself with indie rock?
No. Hey, honey, I would have loved to be part of the indie community. But I wasn’t. I was looking for a community. I don’t even know any people who are musicians. I never met that indie popular indie, whoever the fuck that is. Who IS indie? First of all, I can’t really get my head around what indie music is. Because if you’ve heard of it, it’s sort of pop music, right? Because it’s, like, popular? Or is it just that it’s not on the radio? It’s not like I was in an indie community and then I blew up. It’s like, I was living on the street and I’m not—like, for real, you know what I’m saying?

You didn’t read Pitchfork to find out, like, ‘what’s new in indie’?
No. I knew they were very popular. Rolling Stone and Pitchfork. They were very popular. [laughs and shrugs]. Yeah, it was sort of much farther away than where I was, which was nowhere.

October 15, 2011

Review: Lana Del Rey—Video Games EP (2011)
Mezzic, By John
She’s not authentic. No contest on that, nor debate. The hipsters going to arms over this are, as Gawker remarked, fighting a losing battle.

November 11, 2011

Why the Indie Music World Hates Lana Del Rey
Good, post by Tracy Jeanne Rosenthal
Of course, the indie world’s dirty little secret—and its greatest fear—is that even while claiming innocence, indie reproduces many of the evils of pop. What happens to Lana Del Rey and all those scapegoated, formerly-known-as-indie artists? Cut off like gangrenous appendages, they turn into phantom limbs and haunt the body of indie forever.

2012

January 4, 2012

‘Indie’ Singer Lana Del Rey Lands A Modeling Contract
The Gloss, post by Jamie PeckJanuary 13, 2012

Some Things You Should Know About Lana Del Rey Before She Plays SNL
Crushable, post by Jamie Peck
1.) There have been a lot of Internet fights about her.
This is no accident, as her image seems to have been constructed with “making people angry” as at least a secondary concern. This tactic has become such an easy route to fame that it’s common enough to have a name now: trollgaze. The fact that she is trying to brand (or rather, re-brand, as she used to look quite different and go by her real name, Lizzy Grant) herself as some sort of “Lolita in the hood” (her words, not mine), thereby perpetuating the idea that a book about a child rapist is sexy, the borderline offensive references to the ghetto when she’s the daughter of a wealthy Internet domain guy and went to prep school in Connecticut, the way she’s being branded as an “indie” artist when she was never a part of any D.I.Y. scene, her obvious and distracting surgical augmentation, the fact that she insists on lying about said surgical augmentation, etc.

ldr born to die

I guess the main thing that bothers me about Lana Del Rey is not Lana Del Rey herself, but the endless amounts of attention and money being devoted to her that could be going to more talented, but less pouty and viral, people. This is not Lana Del Rey’s fault, but I still reserve the right to be angry about it.

January 13, 2012

echoing the sound Message Board
Kid Charlemagne: Don’t get me wrong, I’d bang Lana Del Ray, but that SNL performance was one of the worst I’ve seen, and this is the same show that has had Kelly Clarkson (I’d bang her too, even though she has a gut), Marron 5, [sic] Foster the People and Lady Antebellum (would bang that chick in the band too). Though Foster the People were probably worse, their popularity has puzzled me as much as Lana.

Jinsai: so nobody’s mentioned how she was outed for being a manufactured push from a major label to sell a faux indie aesthetic? I thought that was at least interesting.

Kid Charlemagne: That’s Jimmy Iovine for you! He’s going to milk this indie darling until she starts getting lukewarm reviews from Pitchfork, Brooklyn Vegan, Sterogum, etc., kind of like how we were made to hink [sic] Mumford and Sons were the next best thing to Fleet Foxes.

richardp: I was just thinking that earlier while watching SNL. Pitchfork has consistently been hyping her up so much the past few months, but I bet when they review her actual album it’s going to get like a 6.2 or something. Which will kind of prove how much her publicity team is paying all these websites to hype her boring ass jams.

bobbiesolo: i’d put it in her butt, but that’s where this ENDS.

Deadpool (Re: Jinsai’s comment): Ooh, I’d really like to read more about this! If you have any good articles, please share.

I think my first exposure to this girl was her performance on Later with Jools Holland, which I didn’t find good or bad, but completely forgettable. I listened to a remix I liked, then heard “Born to Die” which I thought was enjoyable. The SNL performances are pretty eh to pretty bad. Like you guys have mentioned, it’s a little sickening that she’s already made it to that level of exposure—reminds me of Ashlee Simpson, which is a very bad thing. Yes to the banging, though.

Kid Charlemagne: Del Rey is being marketed almost the same exact way, sans the stupid outfits, to the indie community because she name dropped Kurt Cobain, and for some reason sites like Pitchfork, who are usually good at seeing past these types of artists, have decided to give her coverage based on God knows what.

January 17, 2012

When Lana Del Rey Was Lizzy Grant
Bowery Boogie
Lana Del Rey is the stage name of Lizzy Grant, and that’s how we were acquainted long before all the hype. Through some friends in the music business, we first discovered her sultry yet addictive style during CMJ in 2008, catching a pair of back-to-back performances at the Living Room and National Underground. Shows that revealed the dueling forces of her star power and crippling stage fright. At the time, the Kill Kill EP had just been released, and she had already been gaining some small-time buzz during the annual music fest. Her strong songwriting, vocal delivery, and beauty were enough to captivate, leading to the 2010 release of her self-titled debut on 5 Points Records (as Lana). Now she’s blowing up like whoa, thanks to a major label deal with Interscope.

January 31, 2012

Critic’s Notebook: Lana Del Rey’s ‘Born to Die’ an object lesson in the hazards of hype
The Boston Globe, article by James Reed
From the moment I watched the ballad’s homemade video, I vowed right then that I would follow that voice down a dark alley and relish whatever horrible fate awaited me.

By the time she performed on “Saturday Night Live” this month, she was already doomed. The social-media hive immediately savaged her shaky performance for the very qualities that initially sparked interest in the singer: She’s aloof, practically a caricature of a siren with that mercurial voice, big doe eyes cast downward, and those infamous lips locked in a perma-pout.

That live performance was not her best; I’ve heard others, in which Del Rey colored her songs with guttural dips and wild swoops, that suggested she has real talent beneath that manicured image. And I maintain that “Video Games” is a great song. It’s not a marvel of songwriting, but it was immaculate and seemed like a natural extension of Adele’s heart-on-sleeve pop. If Cat Power had released that song, it would have been a minor hit with no sniping about its origins.
After months of scrutinizing her back story, we finally have her album. It underwhelms.

“Born to Die” did teach me something, though. If I’m going to believe in an artist, she has to believe in herself first.

January 25 – 26, 2012

Conversation on Facebook (to a friend’s Wall Post)
Facebook commenter 1: Oh please! Her performance was not nearly as bad as Guided By Voices on Letterman where the bass player even busted his ass, but did you hear any backlash on those critic’s darlings?

Facebook commenter: GBV has talent. LDR does not. 🙂

Me: In your opinion.

Facebook commenter 2: Well, no doi. Did you see LDR on SNL? It’s been a long time since anyone has shit the bed with such vigor and such enthusiasm. I hope to never again witness such a pathetic spectacle.

Me: No I didn’t see her on SNL, but I’ve heard her other songs and I like them. There are people far more worthy of my vitriol, however.

Facebook commenter 2: Yay for you!

Facebook commenter 2: LDR is an image, a product, a last-ditch effort by corporate rock to pander to the indie set. Her vocal range is very limited. She has no stage presence or personality. Her initial string of live “performances” was abysmal. She stood there chomping gum and looking bored with her sparkly iPhone jammed into he pocket, like she didn’t even want to be there. Not a fan of the “indie-as-fashion-statement” schtick. And the whole “gangsta Nancy Sinatra” thing? I’m amazed that she even knows who Nancy Sinatra is. For those of you who haven’t seen it, here’s LDR’s SNL abortion.

January 26, 2012

How to Fake it in America: Is Lana Del Rey the Kim Kardashian of Pop Music?
Art Nouveau, post by Kendrick ‘GREATeclectic’ Daye
And the Lana Del Rey backlash ensued. A self-referential music fan values authenticity over everything. And with a millionaire father, elaborate cover-ups of previous attempts at fame and the best PR and Marketing team money can buy is putting out the worst example for our generation. As herself, Lizzy Grant, she couldn’t make it. With daddy’s money, a few lip injections and a pin-up makeover and the world is yours.

Amber Rose and The Kardashian clan is enough. Just when you thought they were out of those kind of bimbos, here comes Lana riding blogs like a white horse. No amount of money can buy you experience and talent, or respect for that matter. It’s one thing to suck on your own merit and build up to a stage like SNL or Billboard. But it’s another thing for your daddy, to feel bad when you fall on your ass once, and pump money into your career and poof to make you a star. After watching this, I imagine Daniel Radcliffe was backstage thinking, “fuck, i wish magic was real!”

January 26, 2012

Lana Del Rey Leaves Early Adopters Behind
Hypebot.com, post by Clyde Smith
I have to admit, I ignored the Lana Del Rey phenomenon for a variety of reasons including the fact that great musical artists rarely look like beautiful movie stars and most of the hardcore hype was on sites I don’t follow. But somehow the now controversial Saturday Night Live appearance broke through the walls and, upon closer examination, I realize that Del Rey is a fascinating example of America’s unrealistic expectations for authenticity from performing artists even when they should know better. She is also an example in the arts of what the tech world calls “crossing the chasm” from early adopters to mainstream adoration.

I’m going to have to take various writers’ word that Lana Del Rey got a lot of hype on the web from indie music blogs and websites who ultimately turned on her when she turned out to have a prior identity and was destined to be a pop star. Popjustice has a wonderful takedown of the attacks by previously worshipful music writers when they realized she wasn’t their indie princess any more. But somehow they leave out the fact that we are talking about what are essentially a bunch of boy bloggers of varying ages in love with someone for whom they hoped to someday buy a PBR after her SXSW showcase only to realize that she is untouchable. Sorry, son. She ain’t for the likes of you.

January 27, 2012

Real-life conversation
Other person: Have you guys heard about Lana Del Rey? I hate her, I hate her! She’s trying to infiltrate the indie world.

January 27, 2012

Why Do You Hate Lana Del Rey? I Do Not Know Why I Hate Lana Del Rey
Jezebel, post by two Jezebel editors, Jessica and Dodai
Jessica: No, probably not. But this is hard for me, because I really hate Lana Del Rey. I don’t like her music—I’m depressed enough without depressing music—and I don’t like that the whole thing feels like some sort of “pre-fabricated indie” affair. And the Restalyne (just a guess) combined with her apparent artistic reinvention just makes it seem all the more “fake.”

Comment by girlonfire:
From Wikipedia:
“She is the daughter of domain squatter and millionaire Rob Grant. Grant’s management chose her stage name, ‘I wanted to be a band but the label I was with and the team I had around me absolutely wanted me to be a solo artist.'”

Another quote from her: “Lana Del Rey came from a series of managers and lawyers over the last 5 years who wanted a name that they thought better fit the sound of the music.”

Lana Del Rey isn’t her real name, rather it is the name they thought was best for marketing.

And further down: “Her father, Robert Grant, helped with the marketing of the album.”

She was, quite literally, manufactured. Her father paid for a team of people (for five years to figure out the exact perfect combination of looks and name and sound that would be most successful today. He also paid for her marketing, for her to be on itunes when she barely has any music out yet, etc. No, money can’t buy everything, but if it pays for enough hype, enough publicity, and a contract with a big or important label, it can get you very far (and on SNL).

I genuinely believe the backlash against her is not only valid, but vital for the health of the music industry and, really, music as an art form.

January 30, 2012

Album review: Lana Del Rey’s Born To Die
Vancouver Sun, article by Sandra Sperounes
By the looks of it, Lana Del Rey’s pop career was born to die in a very vicious and public manner.

Only months after being crowned the latest Prom Queen of the Internet on the strength of a series of sensual, ornate, and pseudo-orchestral songs—Video Games, Blue Jeans, and Born To Die—the New York starlet is drawing ire for her looks, her lack of indie credibility, her stilted performance on Saturday Night Live, and her supposed submissiveness as a woman, to name but a few of her crimes against humanity.

Everyone from NBC’s Brian Williams to anonymous YouTube commenters are weighing in on Del Rey’s inadequacies, eviscerating her like a pack of nasty high-school bullies, eager to tear their former best friend to pieces. It’s a ridiculous, if not sad predicament for someone who can actually sing—Del Rey’s voice ranges from hard-to-please sexpot to naive teen to numb party girl—and the potential to be more than a one-hit, five-month wonder.

So she’s not the most engaging performer. (Neither is Avril Lavigne.) So her real name isn’t Lana Del Rey. (It’s Elizabeth, or Lizzy, Grant.) So her dad might be an investor of some sort. (How dare a rich kid write music?) So she released an indie album before honing the ‘60s-soundtrack-pop sound of her Interscope debut, Born To Die, due Tuesday.

Apparently, it’s OK for Lady Gaga and Katy Perry to change their names and sounds—or come from some money as is the case with the artist formerly known as Stefani Germanotta—but Del Rey isn’t accorded the same leeway, partly because she was initially embraced as an indie artist, not a major-label pop star.

Born To Die isn’t such a far cry from what Del Rey was doing on Lana Del Ray A.K.A. Lizzy Grant—the album she released on an indie label in 2010. (She pulled it from circulation only a few months later, but all the songs are currently posted on YouTube. She says she will re-release it this summer.) Lana Del Ray A.K.A. Lizzy Grant, produced by David Kahne, features some of the same retro vibe and lyrical references—sweaters, Coney Island, national anthem—which seems to refute claims by those critics who think she’s just another pop star manufactured by a bunch of producers and record executives.

Even if she is, the real litmus test should be her songs and, of course, her abilities as a performer. She needs to work on both—especially the latter, in this day and age of female pop stars and their over-the-top shows—but at the very least, we should give Del Rey a chance to release and tour Born To Die before we kill her off.

January 30, 2012

Lana Del Rey—Born To Die Album Review
Gossip Celebrity News, post by Mark Dommu
It’s impossible to discuss Lana Del Rey based solely on her music, when her introduction into the popular consciousness is based more on her past and her appearance than the quality of what she’s putting out in the world. So let’s get it out of the way up front: Lana Del Rey has received the Cinderella treatment from her record label, has had her past wiped away and been christened with a new name and aesthetic aimed at making her the newest “indie darling”. Del Rey gives incredibly awkward live performances (is there anyone in America who hasn’t seen her train wreck on Saturday Night Live?) and no matter how many times she claims otherwise there is NO WAY those lips of hers are real.

And with that out of the way, we can get to the real point: Lana Del Rey’s debut album, Born To Die.

January 31, 2012

Lana Del Rey Gets The Superstar Treatment by Fiat
Time Entertainment, post by Gilbert Cruz
If you regularly follow music blogs, or pay attention to new music in general, you’ve probably heard of Del Rey. At the very least, you saw—or read about the backlash against—her languid bordering on narcoleptic Saturday Night Live performance. As Wolk writes, she’s “an online starlet thanks to a couple of low-res YouTube videos.” A rather small but intense debate has raged for several months now about the “authenticity” of Del Rey, who appears to be wholly manufactured in terms of both persona and musical talent, yet is content in passing herself off as some sort of indie musician (whatever that means).

February 6, 2012

Pop Music
Screen Shot: Lana Del Rey’s fixed image.
The New Yorker, article by Sasha Frere-Jones
Surely no equivalent male star would be subject to the same level of examination.

And this is where Del Rey stumbles slightly. “Born to Die” is full of rubbery, well-formed melodies and harmonic richness—who cares who wrote much of it—but the character of Del Rey, authentic or not, is so inconsistent that she fades from view, into her own photo spread.


Editor’s note: Born To Die was released by Interscope Records on January 31. Pitchfork has rated it a 5.5. Lana Del Rey has discussed possibly reissuing her first album. I still have not watched the SNL performance.

2 Responses to “What Is The Deal With Lana Del Rey? A Timeline”


  1. Jemiah:
    February 20th, 2012 at 6:06 pm

    Staggering. Thanks for doing the legwork… I still haven’t listened, but I’m behind on a lot. However, I intend to make up my own mind whenever I actually have the time and mental space to listen critically – or to hear, distracted and drunk at a bar, which is nearly just as good for perceiving the “truth” of some music.

  2. Chelsea:
    February 25th, 2012 at 9:17 am

    I feel badly about this, but one of the reasons I haven’t warmed to her is because the songs I’ve heard remind me so much of Julee Cruise. Why listen to this when I still have my copy of ‘Floating Into The Night’, you know? Yes, this is a stupid reason to feel all meh about her.







Time limit is exhausted. Please reload the CAPTCHA.